A lone quixote in Seattle is suing Autodesk for sending copyright infringement notices to eBay, where he is a professional seller. At issue is Tim Vernor's listings for used copies of Autodesk's AutoCAD software - Autodesk says that when you buy its software, you only 'license' it and so you don't get the right to sell it after you're done with it. Vernor is seeking $10 million.
Related: autodesk autocad 2019 autocad software autocad 2018 autocad license autodesk autocad viker office 2016 makita 18v autocad mac autocad lt solidworks Include description Categories.
Autodesk is using the Digital Millennium Copyright Act to have legal copies of their software removed from eBay so they can sell more new copies. The latest version of AutoCAD software is around $4,000 a copy. Autodesk's lawyer, Andrew S. Mackay states 'AutoCAD software is licensed, not sold and that license is not transferable.' AutoCAD software is available for purchase at most major software retailers. There is no indication your purchase would be different from any other until you get it home and open the box. There is a piece of paper tucked inside that says it is a licensing agreement with the statement 'by opening the sealed software packet(s), you agree to be bound by the terms and conditions of this license agreement'.
This is called a 'shrink wrap' contract. It cannot be read until you open the package which according to the contract constitutes agreement. US courts have not held a 'shrink wrap ' contract to be valid.
Furthermore the Digital Millennium Copyright Act is only intended to enforce copyright violations, not breach of contract. The lawsuit also alleges perjury since the notice that was sent to eBay is required to be signed under penalty of perjury and fraud. Using illegal means to make a legal gain (i.e.
Sell more new copies) is a civil definition of fraud. Autodesk's attorney Andrew S. Mackay is currently under investigation (# 07-24456) by the California State Bar Association for his actions in this matter. Read the rules you agree to by using this website in our. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Boing Boing uses cookies and analytics trackers, and is supported by advertising, merchandise sales and affiliate links.
Read about what we do with the data we gather in our. Who will be eaten first? Our forum rules are detailed in the. Boing Boing is published under except where otherwise noted.